Comprehensive 2025 NYC Mansion Tax Guide for Buyers

The NYC mansion tax is a real estate transfer tax on homes sold for over $1 million in New York City. It's important for homebuyers in 2025 to know about this tax. It helps with budgeting and making smart choices.

Key Takeaways:

• The mansion tax applies to residential properties sold for $1 million or more in NYC
• Rates range from 1% to 3.9%, depending on the purchase price
• The buyer is responsible for paying the mansion tax at closing
• Mansion tax cannot be avoided, but can be offset with strategies like commission rebates

What Is the NYC Mansion Tax?

Definition and Purpose

The NYC mansion tax is a one-time tax for buyers of homes over $1 million. It helps fund the state and city budgets.

Historical Background

The mansion tax started in 1989 to balance the state budget. It was aimed at the wealthiest buyers at the time.

Legislative Basis

The mansion tax is based on New York State Tax Law Section 1402-a. It explains who it applies to, the rates, and how to pay it.

Importance for Homebuyers in 2025

As home prices in NYC keep going up, more buyers face the mansion tax. In 2025, it's key to understand this tax for budgeting and making decisions.

Types of Properties Subject to the NYC Mansion Tax

Residential vs. Commercial

The mansion tax only applies to homes, not businesses. But, homes used for both living and business might be taxed.

New Construction vs. Existing Properties

This tax hits both new and old homes. It matters if they cost over a certain amount.

Personal Residence vs. Investment Property

It doesn't matter if you live in the home or rent it out. The mansion tax applies the same.

Exemptions and Special Cases

There are no general exemptions. But, some transfers, might be free from tax.  Transfers of property between spouses during a divorce are generally exempt from the Mansion Tax, allowing for non-taxable ownership transitions as part of marital settlements. Additionally, first-time homebuyers purchasing their primary residence near the $1 million threshold may qualify for exemptions, as well as properties sold as part of an estate or newly developed units. 

How Much Is the NYC Mansion Tax?

Current thresholds for 2025

For 2025, the mansion tax rates are as follows:

The tax is a percentage of the purchase price. The rate goes up as the price does.

Breakdown by Price Point

Examples at various price tiers

Here are mansion tax examples at different prices:

• $1,500,000 property: 1% mansion tax = $15,000
• $3,500,000 property: 1.5% mansion tax = $52,500
• $12,000,000 property: 3.25% mansion tax = $390,000

Who Pays the NYC Mansion Tax?

Buyer's Responsibility

The buyer must pay the mansion tax at closing. This is on top of other costs like attorney fees and title insurance.

Seller's Responsibility

Occasionally, the buyer and seller might agree for the seller to cover the mansion tax. But this is rare.

Role of Real Estate Agents and Attorneys

Real estate agents and attorneys can help buyers understand their mansion tax duties. They might suggest ways to lower costs, like commission rebates.

Is the NYC Mansion Tax Deductible?

Tax Implications for Buyers

The mansion tax can't be deducted on buyer's federal taxes. But, it can lower their capital gains tax when they sell. This means that when calculating capital gains upon selling, a higher cost basis—comprised of the original purchase price plus certain closing costs including the mansion tax—can potentially reduce capital gains taxes owed.

Possible Deductions or Credits

Even though the mansion tax isn't deductible, other closing costs might be. This includes mortgage interest and real estate taxes.

Consulting a Tax Professional

Talk to a tax expert to understand your home purchase's tax implications. They can help you get the most deductions.

How to Avoid Paying the NYC Mansion Tax

Legal Strategies and Structuring Purchases

There's no legal way to dodge the mansion tax if your home costs over $1 million. But, you can find ways to lessen the financial burden.

Gifting parts of the property

Gifting a portion of property ownership to family members can lower the taxable value and reduce the mansion tax owed. However, this strategy comes with legal implications that necessitate professional guidance to ensure compliance with tax laws.

Commission Rebates from Real Estate Agents

Buyers can negotiate commission rebates from real estate agents as a strategy to offset the mansion tax. These rebates can effectively reduce the purchase price from a taxable perspective, making it possible for buyers to stay under the $1 million threshold.

Using LLCs or other entities

Buying through an LLC or other legal entity won't make you exempt from the mansion tax.

Negotiating with Sellers

It's possible to talk with sellers about splitting or covering the mansion tax. Yet, this is rare and depends on the market.  Buyers may benefit from waiting for a buyer's market when sellers are more likely to negotiate on price or cover part of the mansion tax. This strategy allows buyers to leverage market conditions for better financial outcomes.

How Do I File and Pay the NYC Mansion Tax?

Filing Process

Here's how to file:

1. Fill out Form TP-584, the Combined Real Estate Transfer Tax Return.
2. Send the form and payment to the county recorder's office.
3. The office will process it and give you a receipt.

Forms and Documents Needed

• Form TP-584
• Deed or transfer documents
• Payment (check or money order)

Official Forms

• Form TP-584

Payment Methods and Deadlines

How to Pay

You can pay with a check or money order to the county recorder's office.

Important Dates

The tax is due within 15 days of the transfer. Usually, it's paid at closing with other costs.

When Do You Pay the NYC Mansion Tax?

Timing in the Purchase Process

The mansion tax is paid at closing, along with other costs.

Coordination with Closing Costs

Your attorney will handle the mansion tax payment with other closing costs. This includes transfer taxes, attorney fees, and mortgage fees.

Impact on Transaction Timeline

The mansion tax doesn't usually affect the timeline. It's paid at closing.

Consider the NYC Mansion Tax as Part of Your Closing Costs

Understanding Closing Costs Breakdown

Closing costs in NYC can be 5-6% of the purchase price. This includes the mansion tax, transfer taxes, attorney fees, mortgage fees, and title insurance.

Budgeting for the Mansion Tax

When planning your home purchase, include the mansion tax in your budget. 

Strategies to Manage Overall Closing Expenses

To manage closing costs, consider negotiating with sellers, getting a commission rebate, and finding competitive mortgage rates and title insurance.

Examples of the NYC Mansion Tax in Action

Case Study 1: Commission rebate from Agent

A couple purchasing a $2 million apartment could utilize a commission rebate of $40,000 (2%) from their agent, effectively lowering their taxable amount and reducing their overall financial burden related to the mansion tax.

Case Study 2: Gifting property to family member

A buyer acquiring a $1.5 million property might gift 10% ownership (valued at $150,000) to a family member before purchase. This could reduce their taxable value down below $1.35 million, thereby decreasing their mansion tax liability.

Case Study 3: Capital Gains Tax Implications

Consider a scenario where  if a property is purchased for $1.5 million with a mansion tax of $15,000, this amount increases the cost basis from $1.5 million to $1.515 million. Thus, when selling at a profit, this adjusted basis can lessen capital gains liability.

The Future of the NYC Mansion Tax

Upcoming Legislative Changes

As of 2025, there are no known changes to the mansion tax rates or thresholds. Although, a s discussions surrounding housing affordability continue, there is potential for legislative changes that could impact the Mansion Tax and its exemptions. Stakeholders should monitor developments in local government proposals and public sentiment regarding housing policies, as adjustments could affect both current exemptions and future tax liabilities.

Predictions and Possible Reforms

Some possible reforms that would make this tax more buyer friendly, include:

• Increasing the threshold to account for rising property values
• Adjusting the rates to create a more progressive tax structure
• Earmarking mansion tax revenue for specific purposes, such as affordable housing

Impact on Future Real Estate Markets

The mansion tax may increase the cost of high-end properties. This has lowered demand, although it can be argued how much of an effect it can have in a strong market like New York.

Market Trends

Following the revised mansion tax's implementation in July 2019, Manhattan apartment prices significantly declined, with average prices hitting a four-year low. The luxury market experienced an 88% drop in sales volume in the third quarter of 2019 compared to the previous quarter, with only two homes over $5 million sold shortly after the tax was enacted. Additionally, there has been a marked decrease in homes sold just above the $1 million threshold, with 199 listings priced below this amount compared to only 19 above it, indicating a strategic avoidance of the mansion tax. The market saw a surge in transactions prior to the tax's introduction, but post-implementation, activity slowed considerably as buyers either hesitated or negotiated more aggressively.

Developer Strategies

Developers are adapting by modifying their pricing models and unit sizes. For example, some developers may reduce the size of luxury units or offer incentives that effectively lower the sale price to avoid triggering the mansion tax. This strategic adjustment is crucial in maintaining sales volume in a competitive market.

Additional Considerations for Buyers

Impact on Mortgage Rates and Financing

The mansion tax is paid out of pocket and can't be financed with a mortgage. Some lenders might offer higher mortgage amounts to cover closing costs.

Long-Term Financial Planning and Investment

Consider the mansion tax as part of your initial investment. But, also think about the property's appreciation and tax benefits of homeownership.

Impact on Property Resale Value

The mansion tax is a one-time cost. It doesn't directly affect your property's resale value. But, it might influence buyer demand and pricing in the luxury market.

FAQs About the NYC Mansion Tax

Common Questions Answered

1. Q: Does the mansion tax apply to new construction?
   A: Yes, the mansion tax applies to all residential properties, including new construction, that meet the price threshold.

2. Q: Can I deduct the mansion tax on my income tax return?
   A: No, the mansion tax is not deductible on your federal income tax return. But, it can be added to your cost basis.

3. Q: Is the mansion tax the same for condos and co-ops?
   A: Yes, the mansion tax rates and thresholds are the same for condos and co-ops.

Clarifications on Complex Topics

• The mansion tax is separate from other transfer taxes, such as the NYC and New York State transfer taxes.
• The mansion tax applies to the total purchase price, not just the amount over $1 million.
• The mansion tax is a one-time tax paid at closing and does not recur annually like property taxes.

Link to Official Resources for Further Information

For more information on the NYC mansion tax, visit the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance website.

Conclusion

Summary of Key Points

The NYC mansion tax is a significant closing cost for homebuyers purchasing properties for $1 million or more. Understanding its rates, applicability, and payment process is key for budgeting and decision-making.

Final Advice for Prospective Buyers

When buying a home in NYC, factor in the mansion tax as part of your closing costs. Explore strategies to manage the expense, such as commission rebates and negotiating with sellers.

Consulting with professionals at Robert DeFalco Realty  can be invaluable when navigating this and other closing costs.

Tags

• Buying (16)
• Selling (16)
• New York (15)
• Manhattan (4)
• Brooklyn Heights (1)
• Long Island City (1)
• Upper East Side (1)
• Mansion Tax (1)
• Park Slope (1)
• Soho (1)
• DUMBO (1)
• Astoria (1)
• Midtown (1)
• Brooklyn Bridge Park (1)
• Tribeca (1)
• Williamsburg (1)
• Flushing (1)