Bottom Line Up Front: Staten Island offers exceptional educational opportunities through top-rated public schools like P.S. 5 Huguenot (10/10 rating), nationally-ranked specialized schools including Staten Island Technical High School (#50 nationally), and prestigious private institutions like Staten Island Academy. This comprehensive guide helps families make informed decisions when choosing schools that align with their children’s needs and future goals.
Why School Quality Matters When Choosing Your Staten Island Home
When families consider relocating to Staten Island, school quality becomes a primary driver of both lifestyle satisfaction and long-term investment returns. Research consistently shows that homes in districts with top-performing schools maintain higher property values and experience stronger appreciation over time.
The connection between educational excellence and real estate value runs deeper than simple market dynamics. Quality schools create stable, family-oriented communities where:
- Property values remain resilient during market fluctuations
- Neighborhoods develop strong community ties and civic engagement
- Local businesses thrive due to consistent demographic stability
- Resale potential increases when it’s time to move
For families making the significant investment of homeownership, choosing a location with excellent schools isn’t just about education—it’s about securing your family’s financial future while providing the best possible foundation for your children’s development.
Staten Island School System Overview
Staten Island operates under NYC District 31, serving over 50,000 students across diverse educational pathways. This district structure provides families with multiple high-quality options tailored to different learning styles and career aspirations.
Public School System Structure
The public school system follows New York City’s organizational model:
| School Level | Grades | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| Elementary Schools (P.S.) | K-5 | Neighborhood-based enrollment, foundational academics |
| Intermediate Schools (I.S.) | 6-8 | Subject-specialized teachers, advanced programs |
| High Schools | 9-12 | Specialized programs, college preparation |
Educational Options Available
Public Schools: Traditional neighborhood schools with zoned enrollment, plus specialized programs and magnet schools that accept students borough-wide.
Charter Schools: Independently operated public schools offering innovative curricula, including STEM-focused programs and early college partnerships.
Private Schools: Independent institutions ranging from prestigious college preparatory academies to faith-based schools with strong community ties.
Special Education Services: District 75 provides comprehensive support for students with special needs, ensuring every learner receives appropriate educational opportunities.
According to the NYC Department of Education, Staten Island consistently outperforms citywide averages in reading and mathematics proficiency, making it an attractive destination for families prioritizing academic achievement.
Top-Rated Public Elementary Schools in Staten Island
Elementary school selection forms the foundation of your child’s educational journey. Staten Island’s public elementary schools demonstrate remarkable consistency in delivering quality education across diverse neighborhoods.
North Shore Elementary Schools
P.S. 5 Huguenot stands as Staten Island’s crown jewel, earning a perfect 10/10 GreatSchools rating. Located in the Huguenot neighborhood, this school achieves exceptional results:
- 92% reading proficiency rate (compared to 58% citywide)
- 89% mathematics proficiency
- Advanced gifted and talented programs
- Strong parent engagement with active PTA participation
The school’s success stems from its dedicated faculty, comprehensive enrichment programs, and supportive community environment that fosters both academic excellence and character development.
P.S. 30 Westerleigh serves the growing Westerleigh community with innovative programming that includes:
- STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, Mathematics) integration
- Dual-language programs for multilingual learners
- After-school enrichment in robotics and creative arts
- Strong special education inclusion practices
P.S. 32 The Gifford School rounds out the North Shore’s exceptional offerings with specialized programs in:
- Environmental science and sustainability
- Advanced mathematics tracks
- Arts integration across all subjects
- Community service learning projects
Mid-Island Elementary Schools
The Mid-Island region offers families excellent educational options combined with convenient access to Staten Island’s commercial and recreational centers.
P.S. 23 Richmondtown benefits from its location near Richmondtown, incorporating local history and culture into its curriculum. Students engage with:
- Living history programs at Historic Richmond Town
- Advanced reading intervention programs
- Technology integration in core subjects
- Strong music and arts programs
P.S. 3 Margaret Gioiosa School serves the New Dorp area with:
- Collaborative learning environments
- STEM enrichment programs
- Multilingual support services
- Active family engagement initiatives
These schools consistently demonstrate that quality education isn’t limited to a single neighborhood—Mid-Island families enjoy multiple excellent options within reasonable commuting distance.
South Shore Elementary Schools
South Shore elementary schools combine academic rigor with the relaxed atmosphere of Staten Island’s more suburban communities. Schools in areas like Great Kills and Tottenville consistently rank above district and citywide averages.
Key performance indicators across South Shore elementary schools include:
- Above-average standardized test scores
- High teacher retention rates indicating job satisfaction
- Strong extracurricular offerings including sports and clubs
- Active community partnerships supporting educational programming
The South Shore’s family-friendly atmosphere creates an environment where children can focus on learning while developing social skills in safe, supportive settings.
Best Middle Schools (Intermediate Schools) in Staten Island
The transition to middle school represents a critical juncture in educational development. Staten Island’s intermediate schools excel at providing the structured support students need while introducing them to more specialized academic tracks.
I.S. 075 Frank D. Paulo consistently ranks among New York City’s top middle schools, offering:
- Advanced Regents-level courses for high-achieving students
- Comprehensive arts programs including orchestra and theater
- Competitive sports teams fostering teamwork and discipline
- Honor society chapters recognizing academic and service excellence
I.S. 007 Elias Bernstein specializes in STEM education with:
- Robotics teams competing at regional and state levels
- Advanced mathematics tracks leading to high school calculus
- Science fair programs with consistent award winners
- Technology literacy courses preparing students for digital futures
I.S. 034 Tottenville serves the South Shore with programs emphasizing:
- College and career readiness skills
- Advanced placement preparation courses
- Community service learning requirements
- Leadership development through student government
These intermediate schools successfully bridge elementary education with high school preparation, ensuring students enter their freshman year equipped with both academic knowledge and essential life skills.
Premier High Schools in Staten Island
Staten Island’s high schools offer diverse pathways to college and career success, from specialized STEM programs to comprehensive liberal arts education.
Staten Island Technical High School
Staten Island Technical High School stands as a testament to educational excellence, ranking #50 nationally among all high schools. This specialized institution requires students to pass the Specialized High Schools Admissions Test (SHSAT), ensuring a student body committed to academic achievement.
The school’s exceptional programs include:
- Advanced STEM Curriculum: Students choose from multiple engineering tracks, advanced computer science, and research-based science courses
- College Partnerships: Dual enrollment opportunities with local colleges for qualified students
- Research Programs: Independent research projects mentored by professionals in relevant fields
- College Preparation: 98% college acceptance rate with students attending top-tier universities nationwide
Staten Island Technical High School’s graduates regularly earn admission to MIT, Stanford, Columbia, and other prestigious institutions, making it a premier choice for academically motivated students.
Tottenville High School
Tottenville High School serves as Staten Island’s largest comprehensive high school, offering something for every learning style and career aspiration. Located near quality Tottenville residential areas, the school provides:
- Comprehensive Academic Programs: Over 200 courses including 25+ AP options
- Career and Technical Education: Programs in healthcare, business, and skilled trades
- Arts and Athletics: Championship sports teams and award-winning performing arts programs
- Notable Alumni: Graduates include successful professionals, artists, and community leaders
The school’s size allows for specialized programs that might not be feasible at smaller institutions, giving students access to resources typically found only at specialized schools.
Other Top Public High Schools
New Dorp High School offers families in the New Dorp area excellent educational opportunities with:
- Strong college preparatory programs
- Diverse extracurricular offerings
- Community partnerships enhancing learning opportunities
- Supportive guidance counseling services
Susan E Wagner High School provides comprehensive education with particular strengths in:
- Arts and media programs
- Athletic programs with competitive teams
- Career counseling and college placement services
- Special education inclusion programs
Port Richmond High School serves the North Shore with programs emphasizing:
- Community engagement and service learning
- Multicultural education reflecting neighborhood diversity
- Career and technical education partnerships
- College readiness initiatives
Best Private Schools in Staten Island
For families seeking alternative educational approaches or smaller class sizes, Staten Island’s private schools offer exceptional opportunities for personalized learning and character development.
Staten Island Academy
Staten Island Academy represents the pinnacle of private education on Staten Island, serving students from Pre-K3 through Grade 12. With annual tuition of $41,700, the Academy provides:
Academic Excellence:
- Average class size of 12 students ensuring individual attention
- 100% college acceptance rate with graduates attending Ivy League institutions
- Advanced Placement courses across all major subject areas
- Independent research opportunities and honors programs
Comprehensive Programs:
- STEM initiatives including robotics and engineering
- Extensive arts programs with professional-quality facilities
- Competitive athletics with championship teams
- Community service requirements fostering civic responsibility
Campus and Resources:
- Historic campus with modern facilities
- State-of-the-art science laboratories and technology centers
- Performing arts venues and athletic facilities
- Library resources supporting advanced research projects
Families considering Staten Island Academy benefit from its proximity to Todt Hill and Dongan Hills, areas known for their excellent residential options and family-friendly communities.
Catholic Schools Network
Staten Island’s Catholic schools combine academic rigor with faith-based education, serving families who value moral development alongside intellectual growth.
St. Joseph By The Sea High School offers:
- College preparatory curriculum with high acceptance rates
- Strong athletic programs with competitive teams
- Community service requirements building character
- Tuition assistance programs supporting diverse enrollment
Notre Dame Academy specializes in girls’ education with:
- Leadership development programs
- STEM initiatives encouraging female participation in science and technology
- Arts programs including visual arts, music, and theater
- College counseling with personalized guidance
Academy of St. Dorothy provides:
- Small class sizes with individualized attention
- Technology integration across all subjects
- After-school programs and enrichment activities
- Strong parent-school communication and involvement
St. Peter’s Boys High School focuses on:
- All-male education environment fostering brotherhood and achievement
- Comprehensive athletics and extracurricular programs
- Alumni network providing mentorship and career guidance
- Scholarship opportunities for qualified students
Religious and Specialty Schools
Staten Island Hebrew Academy serves families seeking Jewish education with:
- Dual curriculum combining secular and religious studies
- Hebrew language instruction from early grades
- Cultural programming and community connections
- Small school environment with family atmosphere
St. Teresa-St. Rita STREAM Academy emphasizes:
- STREAM (Science, Technology, Religion, Engineering, Arts, Mathematics) education
- Project-based learning approaches
- Community partnerships enhancing educational experiences
- Faith integration across all subject areas
These institutions provide alternatives for families seeking education aligned with their religious and cultural values while maintaining high academic standards.
Charter and Alternative Schools
Charter schools offer innovation and flexibility within the public education framework, providing families with additional high-quality options.
Integration Charter Schools operates multiple locations with:
- Extended learning time through longer school days and years
- College preparatory focus from elementary grades
- Data-driven instruction tailoring learning to individual needs
- High expectations for both academic achievement and character development
Richmond Prep Computer Science Program specializes in:
- Technology-focused curriculum preparing students for modern careers
- Industry partnerships providing real-world learning experiences
- Project-based learning emphasizing practical application
- College and career counseling aligned with technology fields
Early College High School options allow qualified students to:
- Earn college credits while completing high school requirements
- Reduce time and cost of post-secondary education
- Experience college-level coursework with high school support
- Develop independence and academic maturity
These alternatives serve students whose learning styles or career goals align better with specialized approaches than traditional school settings provide.
School Selection Guide for Staten Island Families
Choosing the right school requires careful consideration of multiple factors that will impact your child’s educational experience and your family’s daily life.
Factors to Consider
Academic Performance Metrics
Beyond test scores, evaluate schools based on:
- Student growth over time, not just achievement levels
- College acceptance rates and scholarship awards
- Advanced course offerings and specialized programs
- Teacher qualifications and professional development opportunities
School Culture and Environment
Visit schools during regular hours to observe:
- Student-teacher interactions and classroom dynamics
- Discipline policies and behavioral expectations
- Diversity and inclusion practices
- Overall atmosphere and school pride
Consider how well the school’s culture aligns with your family’s values and your child’s personality.
Transportation and Location
Practical considerations include:
- Commute time and transportation options
- Before and after-school care availability
- Safety of routes to school
- Impact on family schedule and logistics
Special Programs and Extracurriculars
Evaluate opportunities for:
- Gifted and talented programming
- Special education services if needed
- Arts, music, and athletic programs
- Clubs and leadership development opportunities
Class Sizes and Teacher-to-Student Ratios
Smaller ratios generally provide:
- More individualized attention
- Greater opportunity for student participation
- Stronger teacher-student relationships
- Better classroom management and learning environment
Neighborhood School Quality by Area
Understanding school quality by geographic area helps families make informed decisions about where to live while considering educational priorities.
North Shore: West Brighton, Port Richmond, Stapleton
This historically diverse area offers:
- Strong elementary schools with multilingual support services
- Community partnerships enhancing educational programming
- Affordable housing options with access to quality education
- Cultural diversity enriching student experiences
Mid-Island: New Dorp, Dongan Hills, Grant City
The heart of Staten Island provides:
- Consistent school quality across multiple neighborhoods
- Convenient access to transportation and commercial areas
- Balanced residential communities with stable demographics
- Multiple school options within reasonable distances
Families considering New Dorp or Dongan Hills benefit from this area’s central location and educational consistency.
South Shore: Tottenville, Great Kills, Annadale
The more suburban South Shore features:
- Newer school facilities with modern technology
- Lower student-teacher ratios in many schools
- Strong community support for educational initiatives
- Family-friendly neighborhoods with excellent safety records
Areas like Great Kills and Tottenville offer the perfect combination of suburban comfort and educational excellence.
Todt Hill/Emerson Hill: Premium School Districts
Staten Island’s most affluent area provides:
- Access to both top public schools and prestigious private institutions
- Higher property values supporting robust school funding
- Community resources enhancing educational opportunities
- Proximity to cultural and recreational amenities
Todt Hill residents enjoy easy access to Staten Island Academy and other premium educational options.
Transportation and Accessibility
Getting to school safely and efficiently impacts both student well-being and family logistics. Staten Island’s transportation infrastructure supports various school choice options.
School Bus Services
NYC District 31 provides:
- Free transportation for students living beyond walking distance from their zoned schools
- Special education transportation with trained personnel
- MetroCard programs for high school students using public transit
- Safety protocols ensuring secure pick-up and drop-off procedures
Alternative Transportation Options
Families have access to:
- Public bus routes connecting all major neighborhoods
- Park-and-ride facilities for families driving students to specialized programs
- Bicycle-friendly routes in many areas
- Walking school bus programs promoting community engagement and physical activity
Safety Considerations
Transportation safety features include:
- Crossing guards at major intersections near schools
- School zone speed limits and enforcement
- Regular route evaluations for optimal safety
- Emergency protocols for transportation disruptions
Understanding these transportation realities helps families make practical decisions about school choice based on their specific circumstances and needs.
Enrollment Process and Timeline
Successfully navigating Staten Island’s school enrollment requires understanding different timelines and requirements for various school types.
Public School Registration
Elementary and Middle School (Zoned Schools):
- Registration typically occurs in spring for following school year
- Required documents include proof of residence, birth certificate, and immunization records
- Parents should contact their zoned school directly for specific requirements
- Transfer students can register throughout the year based on space availability
High School Applications:
- Applications must be submitted through MySchools.nyc platform
- Application period typically runs from October through December
- Students can list up to 12 program choices in order of preference
- Specialized high schools require additional testing (SHSAT)
Specialized High School Admissions (SHSAT)
Students seeking admission to Staten Island Technical High School must:
- Register for SHSAT testing during 8th grade
- Take the exam typically in October or November
- Score competitively among all NYC test-takers
- Submit specialized high school applications separate from regular high school applications
Preparation resources include:
- Free test prep programs through NYC Department of Education
- Practice tests and study materials available online
- Private tutoring services for additional support
- School-based guidance counseling for application strategy
Private School Application Processes
Private school admissions vary by institution but typically include:
Application Materials:
- Completed application forms with essays
- Academic transcripts and teacher recommendations
- Standardized test scores (SSAT, ISEE, or school-specific exams)
- Family interviews with admissions committees
Timeline Considerations:
- Applications typically due between December and February
- Testing should be completed by fall of application year
- Financial aid applications have separate deadlines
- Notification dates vary by school, typically in March or April
Financial Aid and Scholarships:
- Need-based aid available at most private schools
- Merit scholarships for exceptional academic or artistic achievement
- Payment plan options to spread tuition costs
- External scholarship opportunities through community organizations
Supporting Your Child’s Education in Staten Island
Quality education extends beyond the school building through community resources and family engagement opportunities that enrich learning experiences.
Parent Involvement Opportunities
Staten Island schools encourage family participation through:
School-Based Organizations:
- Parent-Teacher Associations (PTAs) influencing school policies and programs
- School Leadership Teams including parent representatives
- Volunteer opportunities in classrooms, libraries, and special events
- Fundraising committees supporting enhanced programming
Educational Committees:
- Curriculum committees reviewing and improving academic programs
- Safety committees addressing security and emergency procedures
- Budget committees providing community input on resource allocation
- Special education committees advocating for student needs
Tutoring and Enrichment Programs
Academic support services include:
Free Public Resources:
- After-school tutoring programs at most public schools
- Summer learning programs preventing academic slide
- Library-based homework help and research support
- Peer tutoring programs connecting older and younger students
Private Options:
- Subject-specific tutoring centers
- Test preparation for standardized exams and college admissions
- Enrichment programs in STEM, arts, and other specialized areas
- College counseling services for high school students
Community Resources and Libraries
Staten Island’s educational ecosystem extends through:
Public Library System:
- Multiple branch locations with extensive children’s and teen programming
- Computer access and digital literacy training
- Quiet study spaces and group meeting rooms
- Research assistance and database access for academic projects
Cultural Institutions:
- College of Staten Island offering community programs and events
- Wagner College providing cultural and educational opportunities
- Historic Richmond Town offering living history educational programs
- Staten Island Zoo and other educational attractions
Community Centers:
- Youth programs supporting academic achievement
- Sports and recreation activities promoting physical fitness
- Arts and cultural programming developing creative skills
- Leadership development opportunities for older students
These resources create a comprehensive support network ensuring that quality education extends well beyond traditional school hours and settings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best elementary schools in Staten Island for young children?
A: The top-rated elementary schools in Staten Island include P.S. 5 Huguenot with a perfect 10/10 GreatSchools rating, P.S. 30 Westerleigh in the Mid-Island area, and P.S. 32 The Gifford School. These schools consistently demonstrate high reading and math proficiency rates, with P.S. 5 Huguenot achieving 92% reading proficiency compared to the 58% citywide average.
Q: Is Staten Island Technical High School hard to get into?
A: Staten Island Technical High School is a specialized high school requiring students to take the SHSAT (Specialized High Schools Admissions Test). As the #50 ranked high school nationally, admission is competitive, but the school offers exceptional STEM programs and college preparation for accepted students with a 98% college acceptance rate.
Q: How do Staten Island schools compare to other NYC boroughs?
A: Staten Island schools, part of NYC District 31, consistently outperform many other NYC districts. Top schools like Staten Island Technical High School rank nationally, and the borough offers smaller class sizes and more suburban school environments compared to Manhattan or Brooklyn while maintaining high academic standards.
Q: What private school options are available in Staten Island?
A: Staten Island offers excellent private school options including Staten Island Academy (Pre-K3-12, $41,700 tuition), Notre Dame Academy for girls, St. Joseph By The Sea High School, and several Catholic elementary schools. These schools typically offer smaller class sizes, specialized programs, and strong college preparation.
Q: Which Staten Island neighborhoods have the best schools for families?
A: Top school neighborhoods include Huguenot (home to P.S. 5), Tottenville (excellent high school), Todt Hill/Emerson Hill area (near Staten Island Academy), and Westerleigh (strong elementary options). These areas also tend to have higher property values due to school quality and offer diverse housing options for families.
Q: How do I register my child for school in Staten Island?
A: New residents should contact NYC District 31 directly or visit MySchools.nyc for enrollment information. You’ll need proof of residence, immunization records, and birth certificate. For specialized high schools, students must take the SHSAT in 8th grade, while private schools have separate application processes with varying deadlines.
Q: Are there good schools near the Staten Island Ferry?
A: The St. George area near the ferry has several good school options including P.S. 31 St. George and access to charter schools. Many families in this area also consider the convenient commute access to Manhattan schools and appreciate the cultural diversity of North Shore educational options.
Q: What extracurricular activities do Staten Island schools offer?
A: Staten Island schools offer diverse programs including robotics competitions, sports teams, theater programs, and STEM clubs. Staten Island Technical High School is particularly known for its advanced science and technology programs, while private schools often offer extensive arts and athletics with state-of-the-art facilities.
Key Takeaway: Staten Island provides exceptional educational opportunities across all grade levels, from top-rated elementary schools like P.S. 5 Huguenot to nationally-ranked institutions like Staten Island Technical High School. Whether you choose public, private, or charter options, the borough’s commitment to educational excellence, combined with its family-friendly communities and reasonable real estate prices, makes it an ideal location for families prioritizing both quality education and long-term investment value.
For families ready to make Staten Island home, exploring the complete range of available properties in school districts that match your educational priorities is the perfect next step toward securing your family’s future.