Click for the listing page for 24-26 York Avenue →
Welcome to 24-26 York Avenue, where modern sophistication meets timeless investment potential in the heart of New Brighton. This exceptional two-family property delivers everything savvy investors and extended families have been searching for—two spacious 3-bedroom apartments, freshly renovated with no detail overlooked, positioned perfectly in one of Staten Island’s most desirable neighborhoods.
This remarkable 6-over-6 configuration spans 1,992 square feet of living space on a generous 3,069 square foot lot, offering the rare combination of luxury finishes and practical functionality. Each apartment has been completely transformed with brand-new floors, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and bathrooms that feel more boutique hotel than basic necessity. The finished basement provides endless possibilities for family gatherings or private retreats, while the backyard beckons with summer evening potential and that quintessential barbecue atmosphere.
Interior Features That Define Modern Living
The heart of 24-26 York Avenue lies in its thoughtful renovation, where every surface, fixture, and corner has been redone with meticulous care—no shortcuts, no half-measures. This commitment to quality transforms daily living into something special, whether you’re an owner-occupant enjoying the luxury or an investor maximizing rental potential.
Each of the six bedrooms throughout both units offers generous space and abundant natural light, creating serene environments perfect for rest and relaxation. The thoughtful layouts ensure privacy while maintaining the flow that modern families crave. With ample closet space and versatile room configurations, each bedroom can easily adapt to different lifestyle needs, whether serving as home offices, guest rooms, or peaceful personal retreats.
The two completely renovated kitchens showcase the property’s commitment to contemporary living. Featuring granite countertops that gleam under natural light and stainless steel appliances that blend functionality with style, these culinary spaces inspire both everyday cooking and special occasion entertaining. The modern finishes create a sophisticated atmosphere while maintaining the practical elements that busy families need.
Two updated bathrooms serve the property with modern fixtures and elegant finishes that add touches of luxury to daily routines. These spaces demonstrate the property’s attention to detail, ensuring comfort and convenience for all residents while maintaining the high-end aesthetic found throughout both units.
Exceptional Exterior Features and Practical Amenities
The exterior of 24-26 York Avenue enhances the property’s appeal with features designed for both convenience and enjoyment. The finished basement offers a world of possibilities—from family movie nights to private workout spaces, this versatile area adds significant usable square footage to an already impressive property.
The backyard provides that coveted outdoor space where summer evenings come alive. Perfect for barbecues, children’s play, or quiet moments under the stars, this outdoor sanctuary offers residents a slice of suburban tranquility right in the city. The space accommodates outdoor furniture, grilling stations, and family gatherings, making it an extension of the home’s living areas.
Key Property Highlights:
- Built-in two-car garage eliminating parking stress in a borough where convenient parking is worth its weight in gold
- Separate utilities for each unit, enhancing privacy and allowing individual expense management
- Turn-key condition requiring no immediate investment or renovation work
- Flexible living arrangements perfect for extended families or investment purposes
This combination of practical amenities and luxury finishes creates a property that satisfies both immediate needs and long-term investment goals. The garage alone provides immense value in New Brighton, where parking can be challenging and expensive.
Location and Neighborhood (Staten Island, NY 10301)
New Brighton stands as one of Staten Island’s most architecturally significant and culturally rich neighborhoods. Located on the North Shore, this historic area offers residents the perfect blend of suburban tranquility and urban accessibility. Originally incorporated as a village in 1866, New Brighton has transformed from an industrial hub to a desirable residential community known for its Victorian architecture and strong sense of community.
The neighborhood’s crown jewel is the renowned Snug Harbor Cultural Center and Botanical Garden, an 83-acre historic campus that originally served as a retirement home for sailors and now functions as a premier cultural destination with gardens, museums, theaters, and educational spaces. This National Historic Landmark adds immense cultural value to the area while providing residents with year-round entertainment and educational opportunities.
New Brighton’s strategic location provides excellent transportation connectivity to the rest of New York City. Residents can access several local bus routes including the S40, S42, S44, S46, S52, and S96, which makes travel quite easy through Staten Island to the ferry terminals for connections to other boroughs. The proximity to the Staten Island Ferry ensures a quick 25-minute commute to Manhattan, making New Brighton particularly attractive to working professionals.
Community Amenities and Local Attractions:
The area surrounding 24-26 York Avenue offers residents access to diverse amenities that enhance daily living. Richmond Terrace provides waterfront dining and shopping options with spectacular harbor views. The neighborhood features several historical churches and buildings that add character and prestige to the community.
Local parks and recreational facilities create opportunities for outdoor activities and family gatherings. The architectural diversity in New Brighton speaks to the historical context of the area and the waves of development it has seen over the years. The Victorian homes, particularly those preserved in Hamilton Park, represent some of Staten Island’s most interesting architectural options.
Educational opportunities abound with well-regarded public schools serving the community. P.S. 31 William T Davis and local intermediate schools provide quality education within walking distance, making the neighborhood particularly appealing to families with school-age children.
Why This Property Stands Apart in Today’s Market
24-26 York Avenue represents more than just a real estate purchase—it’s an opportunity to secure a piece of New York City’s future. With rental prices rising by 5.6% across New York City as of January 2025, homeownership becomes an attractive long-term investment, and this property positions owners to benefit from multiple revenue streams while building equity.
The turn-key nature of this investment eliminates the typical challenges associated with older properties. Every major system and finish has been updated, meaning new owners can immediately focus on enjoying their investment rather than managing renovation projects. This rare combination of modern amenities within a classic building structure appeals to today’s renters who seek contemporary comfort without sacrificing character.
For extended families seeking to live together while maintaining independence, the separate utilities and private entrances create the perfect solution. Each unit functions completely independently while sharing the benefits of the prime location and beautiful outdoor space.
Investment Advantages:
Immediate Income Potential: Both units can command premium rental rates due to their move-in ready condition and desirable location. The strong rental market in New Brighton, driven by its ferry accessibility and community amenities, ensures consistent demand from quality tenants.
Long-term Appreciation: New Brighton’s historic significance and ongoing development of nearby cultural attractions support steady property value growth. The neighborhood’s designation as a historic district provides additional protection for property values while limiting overdevelopment.
Tax Benefits: Multi-family property ownership offers various tax advantages, including depreciation benefits and deductible maintenance expenses that can significantly impact overall investment returns.
Experience the Future of Staten Island Living
According to recent market data from Realtor.com, Staten Island’s housing market shows a median price of $710,000, representing a 7.6% increase since last year, demonstrating the borough’s continued appreciation potential. This upward trend, combined with 24-26 York Avenue’s competitive pricing at $999,999, positions this property as an exceptional value in today’s market.
The property exemplifies the perfect intersection of location, condition, and potential that smart investors and families seek. With New Brighton’s rich history, cultural amenities, and strong transportation connections, residents enjoy the best of both urban convenience and suburban comfort.
24-26 York Avenue offers the rare opportunity to own a completely renovated, income-producing property in one of Staten Island’s most prestigious neighborhoods. Whether your goal is multi-generational living or building an investment portfolio, this property delivers the quality, location, and potential that create lasting value.
How to View 24-26 York Avenue, Staten Island NY 10301
- Contact: Robert DeFalco Realty at (718) 987-7900
- Agent: Ragheb Mick Baig
- Agency: Robert DeFalco Realty
- View the listing page for the two-family property located at 24-26 York Avenue, Staten Island NY 10301.
Don’t miss this exceptional opportunity to own a turn-key investment property in New Brighton’s most desirable location. Your future in Staten Island real estate starts here—where modern luxury meets timeless value in the heart of one of New York City’s most charming neighborhoods.