The phones started ringing at 9:47 AM on November 6—48 hours after election results cemented a Mamdani victory. By Monday morning, a stark divide had emerged: Manhattan luxury contracts surged while Staten Island first-time buyers hit the brakes. Here’s what the data reveals.
Election Week Market Shock: By the Numbers
Manhattan’s luxury market ($2M+) saw 18 contracts signed November 6-8, a 40% jump from the previous week’s 13 deals, according to showing data from StreetEasy and internal tracking at Robert DeFalco Realty. The showing request heat map tells the story: Upper East Side and Tribeca glowed red with +65% showing volume, while Staten Island’s Tottenville and Annadale neighborhoods cooled to blue at -35%.
Side-by-side comparison (Nov 6-8 vs. Oct 30-Nov 1):
| Metric | Manhattan Luxury | Staten Island First-Time |
|---|---|---|
| Contracts Signed | 18 (+40%) | 11 (-22%) |
| Avg. Price | $3.2M | $685K |
| Cash Deals | 90% | 12% |
| Days to Offer | 4.2 days | 18 days (withdrawn) |
Manhattan Luxury Market: Fear-Driven Frenzy
The surge wasn’t fueled by confidence—it was policy panic. Buyers rushed to lock in deals before Mamdani’s promised rent stabilization expansion and mansion tax hike take effect. One $4.1M contract at 150 West 56th Street closed in 36 hours, with the buyer wire-transferring a 50% down payment to avoid any financing contingencies.
“In 20 years, I’ve never seen this level of urgency post-election,” noted Robert DeFalco’s analysis. “These buyers aren’t speculating—they’re hedging.” The profile is clear: 90% cash, average age 52, primary residence buyers who voted for Curtis Sliwa but lost.
Staten Island First-Time Buyer Freeze
While Manhattan raced, Staten Island’s first-time buyer market—typically 70% of the borough’s activity—froze. Contract signings dropped to 11 deals from 14 the prior week, but the real story is in withdrawn offers: three buyers pulled out after results, citing “policy uncertainty.”
The average mortgage amount of $625K (95% LTV) makes this demographic exceptionally rate- and policy-sensitive. Showing requests plummeted -35% in Tottenville and Annadale, where 71% of voters backed Cuomo. One Annadale agent reported: “My client called Wednesday morning and said, ‘If Mamdani’s freezing rents, I’m freezing my house hunt.'”
Key Drivers: Why Markets Diverged in 48 Hours
The split hinges on policy exposure. Manhattan luxury buyers fear Mamdani’s platform: expanded rent stabilization affecting 1-million-plus units, potential pied-à-terre tax, and free buses funded by property tax hikes. This creates a “policy fear premium”—buy now, lock in current tax structure.
Meanwhile, Staten Island’s working-class base (average household income $81K) worries about spillover effects: rent control depressing landlord investment, reduced property values, and mortgage qualification tightening as banks price in policy risk. The demographic alignment is precise—Staten Island gave Cuomo 71% of its vote, while Manhattan’s wealth corridors went 58% for Sliwa.
What This Means for Your Market Timing
For Manhattan Sellers: List before Inauguration Day. The window is narrow—cash buyers are racing the clock. Price aggressively; offers are coming in 2-3% above ask to secure deals.
For Staten Island Buyers: Wait for clarity. Inventory will build as uncertainty lingers. Expect 3-5% price softening by Q1 2026, especially in sub-$700K range.
For Brooklyn Investors: Watch for spillover. Manhattan luxury refugees may target Brooklyn brownstones in Brooklyn Tech zones. Showing upticks in Fort Greene suggest early movement.
72-Hour Forecast: Will Trends Hold?
Early November 9-10 data shows Manhattan momentum slowing—weekend showing requests dipped 12% from Friday’s peak. Staten Island remains frozen, with only 2 new contracts Sunday. Robert DeFalco analysis predicts Manhattan’s surge is 72-hour window; Staten Island’s freeze could last 30-45 days until Mamdani clarifies policy timeline.
“Election shocks are temporary, but policy changes are permanent,” the analysis concludes. “Manhattan’s buyers are front-running legislation; Staten Island’s are waiting for certainty.”
Act Now: Get Live Market Alerts
The election created a two-speed market—one racing, one waiting. Don’t get caught on the wrong side.
Call (718) 987-7900 or schedule your market consultation to receive:
- 24-hour alert system for new Manhattan luxury listings
- Staten Island price drop notifications
- Weekly market pulse reports through inauguration