Single Family Homes for Sale in Staten Island NY

Staten Island offers 524+ single family homes for sale with prices ranging from $400,000 to $2,500,000. Browse detached homes, semi-attached houses, and newly constructed properties across Staten Island’s neighborhoods. Robert DeFalco Realty provides expert guidance for buying single family homes in Staten Island since 1990.

Types of Single Family Homes

All Single Family Homes for Sale Listings

Sort by:

Current Single Family Home Inventory Staten Island

Market Statistics (September 2025):

Available Properties: 524 single family homes
Median Price: $725,000
Price Per Square Foot: $442-$474
Average Days on Market: 41 days
Year-over-Year Growth: 8.2% price appreciation
Property Types: Detached, semi-attached, attached homes

Types of Single Family Homes Available

Detached Single Family Homes

Detached single family homes in Staten Island feature private driveways, front yards, and backyards. These properties range from 1,200 to 5,000+ square feet with 3-6 bedrooms. Popular in neighborhoods like Tottenville, Great Kills, and Annadale.

Semi-Attached Single Family Houses

Semi-attached homes share one wall with neighboring property while maintaining separate entrances and yards. Common in New Dorp, Eltingville, and Huguenot areas. Typical size: 1,500-2,500 square feet.

Newly Constructed Single Family Homes

New construction single family homes feature modern amenities, energy-efficient systems, and updated layouts. Located primarily in developing areas of Staten Island with prices starting at $750,000.

Top Staten Island Neighborhoods for Single Family Homes

Annadale Single Family Homes

Annadale offers 150+ single family homes with excellent PS 75 and IS 7 school ratings. Median home price: $650,000. Features tree-lined streets and family-friendly atmosphere.

Key Features:

Average lot size: 6,000 square feet
Home styles: Colonial, Cape Cod, Ranch
Built: 1950s-1980s primarily
School ratings: Above Staten Island average

Great Kills Waterfront Homes

Great Kills features 200+ single family homes near Great Kills Park and marina. Waterfront properties range $850,000-$1,600,000. Many homes offer Staten Island’s south shore water views.

Property Details:

Waterfront lots: 8,000-15,000 square feet
Home types: Contemporary, Tudor, Colonial
Amenities: Private beaches, boat access
Transportation: Express bus to Manhattan

New Dorp Central Location

New Dorp contains 180+ single family homes near Staten Island Mall and Hylan Boulevard shopping. SIR train access to Manhattan. Home prices: $550,000-$950,000.

Location Benefits:

Transit: New Dorp Station (SIR)
Shopping: Within 1 mile of major retailers
Schools: PS 41, IS 51 nearby
Healthcare: Staten Island University Hospital close

Tottenville Historic District

Tottenville offers 120+ single family homes in Staten Island’s southernmost area. Historic properties and new construction available. Average price: $700,000-$1,300,000.

Unique Features:

Lot sizes: 7,000-20,000 square feet
Architecture: Victorian, Colonial, Custom builds
Features: Conference House Park proximity
Character: Historic charm with modern updates

Eltingville Family Community

Eltingville provides 140+ single family homes with newer construction and family amenities. Strong community feel with active neighborhood association. Price range: $625,000-$1,000,000.

Community Assets:

Recreation: Eltingville Transit Center nearby
Shopping: Local businesses and chain stores
Parks: Multiple playgrounds and green spaces
Demographics: Young families and professionals

Single Family Home Buying Guide Staten Island

What to Evaluate in Staten Island Single Family Homes

1. Property Condition Assessment

Roof age and condition (average replacement: $15,000-$25,000)
HVAC system efficiency and age
Electrical panel capacity (200-amp recommended)
Plumbing system materials and condition
Foundation integrity and basement waterproofing

2. Lot Size and Zoning

Staten Island minimum lot sizes: R1 (7,500 sq ft), R2 (5,000 sq ft)
Setback requirements and building coverage limits
Flood zone classifications (important for insurance)
Future development potential and restrictions

3. School District Analysis

Elementary school zones and ratings
Middle school options and performance
High school assignments and specialized programs
Private school alternatives in area

According to the New York State Department of Education, Staten Island schools consistently rank among NYC’s top performers, with many elementary schools achieving 4-5 star ratings.

4. Transportation Access

Staten Island Railway (SIR) station proximity
Express bus routes to Manhattan
Major highway access (Staten Island Expressway, West Shore Expressway)
Ferry terminal distance and parking availability

Staten Island Single Family Home Price Analysis

Neighborhood	Median Price	Price/Sq Ft	Average Size	Lot Size
Great Kills	$775,000	$485	1,850 sq ft	7,200 sq ft
New Dorp	$725,000	$455	1,650 sq ft	6,800 sq ft
Annadale	$650,000	$425	1,520 sq ft	6,000 sq ft
Tottenville	$745,000	$465	1,780 sq ft	8,500 sq ft
Eltingville	$700,000	$445	1,620 sq ft	6,500 sq ft

Benefits of Owning Single Family Homes in Staten Island

Privacy and Space Benefits

Complete Independence: Single family homes provide total privacy with no shared walls, separate utilities, and independent maintenance control. Average lot sizes range 6,000-15,000 square feet.

Outdoor Living: Private yards allow gardening, entertaining, children’s play areas, and pet ownership. Many properties include driveways accommodating 2-4 vehicles.

Investment and Financial Advantages

Equity Building: Staten Island single family homes appreciate 3-5% annually over 10-year periods. Lower property taxes compared to Manhattan and Brooklyn. According to U.S. Census Bureau data, Staten Island (Richmond County) has the highest homeownership rate among NYC boroughs at 78.4%.

Rental Potential: Basement apartments (where legal) provide additional income. Average rental income: $1,400-$2,200 monthly for accessory units.

Family Living Benefits

School Access: Excellent public schools including specialized high schools. Many neighborhoods feature top-rated elementary and middle schools.

Community Feel: Established neighborhoods with block associations, community events, and long-term residents. Safe streets ideal for families with children.

Frequently Asked Questions About Staten Island Single Family Homes

How many single family homes are for sale in Staten Island?

Currently, 524 single family homes are available for sale in Staten Island NY, ranging from $399,000 to $2,695,000. New listings appear weekly with average inventory turnover of 41 days.

What is the average price of single family homes in Staten Island?

The median price for single family homes in Staten Island is $725,000 as of September 2025, with price per square foot ranging from $442-$474. Prices vary by neighborhood and property condition.

Which Staten Island neighborhoods have the most single family homes?

Great Kills, New Dorp, Annadale, and Tottenville contain the highest concentrations of single family homes for sale in Staten Island. These areas offer diverse price points and property styles.

What are typical lot sizes for Staten Island single family homes?

Average lot sizes range from 6,000 square feet in developed areas to 20,000 square feet in waterfront locations. Minimum zoning requirements vary by district: R1 zones require 7,500 sq ft, R2 zones need 5,000 sq ft.

How long do single family homes stay on the market in Staten Island?

Single family homes in Staten Island average 41 days on market as of September 2025. Well-priced properties in desirable neighborhoods often sell within 30-60 days due to strong buyer demand.

Why Choose Robert DeFalco Realty for Staten Island Single Family Homes

Established Expertise: Robert DeFalco Realty has specialized in Staten Island single family homes since 1990. Our agents have completed 3,000+ single family home transactions across Staten Island’s neighborhoods.

Our Single Family Home Services Include:

Market Analysis Services

Detailed neighborhood market data for all Staten Island areas
Comparative market analysis (CMA) for property valuation
Price trend analysis and appreciation projections
Investment potential assessment

Property Evaluation Services

Professional assessment of home condition and value
Inspection coordination and report analysis
Renovation cost estimates and contractor recommendations
Energy efficiency and utility cost analysis

Educational and Community Research

Complete school district information and ratings
Recreation facility and park proximity data
Shopping, dining, and entertainment options overview
Community demographics and lifestyle analysis

Transaction Management

Connections with Staten Island mortgage specialists
Attorney and home inspector referrals
Full-service closing coordination
Post-sale support and local service recommendations

Our Track Record:

34 years serving Staten Island families
98% customer satisfaction rating
3,000+ successful single family home transactions
Exclusive access to off-market properties and pre-market listings

Start Your Staten Island Single Family Home Search

Ready to explore single family homes for sale in Staten Island NY? Contact Robert DeFalco Realty today for personalized property recommendations and neighborhood tours.

Browse Our Services:

Our Listings – View all available properties
Our Agents – Meet our experienced team
Blog – Staten Island real estate insights
Contact Us – Schedule a consultation

Next Steps:

Schedule Consultation: Discuss your family’s needs and budget
Neighborhood Tours: Explore Staten Island communities in person
Property Viewings: See homes matching your criteria
Market Analysis: Understand pricing and negotiation strategies
Purchase Process: Complete transaction with expert guidance

Service Areas: All Staten Island neighborhoods including Annadale, Great Kills, New Dorp, Tottenville, Eltingville, Huguenot, Oakwood, Richmondtown, and Stapleton.

Last Updated: September 2025 | Market data sources: Staten Island MLS, OneKey MLS