Skip to content
Prince’s Bay Hero Image

Homes For Sale In Prince’s Bay

Prince's Bay

Prince’s Bay is a great neighborhood in Staten Island, New York, ideal for those seeking a quieter lifestyle. The area offers a coastal atmosphere, plenty of recreational activities, and a strong community vibe. It features diverse housing options, including single-family homes and townhouses, to suit various needs and preferences.

Homes For Sale In Prince’s Bay

Sort by:

$420,000

24 Marscher Place, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
1 BATH
716 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Detached
MLS ® # 2504698

$549,000

37 Depew Place, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
1 BATH
1,012 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Detached
MLS ® # 2504126

$599,999

1032 Rathbun Avenue A, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
2 BATHS
960 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Attached
MLS ® # 2501251

$635,000

94 Sharrott Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
3 BEDS
3 BATHS
1,340 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Attached
MLS ® # 2504090

$649,000

139 Commodore Drive, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
3 BATHS
1,518 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Attached
MLS ® # 2505079

$679,999

416 Bradford Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
2 BATHS
920 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Detached
MLS ® # 2504155

$729,000

109 Commodore Drive, Staten Island, NY, 10309
2 BEDS
5 BATHS
2,337 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Attached
MLS ® # 2504260

$749,000

52 Cordelia Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
3 BEDS
3 BATHS
1,204 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Detached
MLS ® # 2503485

$749,900

180 Bayview Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
3 BEDS
1 BATH
1,768 BUILDING SQFT
Two Family - Detached
MLS ® # 2501366

$768,288

980 Rensselaer Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
3 BEDS
3 BATHS
1,512 BUILDING SQFT
Single Family - Semi-Attached
MLS ® # 2504692

$829,900

1046 Rensselaer Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
4 BEDS
2 BATHS
1,440 BUILDING SQFT
Two Family - Semi-Attached
MLS ® # 2503232

$829,900

263 Seguine Avenue, Staten Island, NY, 10309
3 BEDS
3 BATHS
1,778 BUILDING SQFT
Two Family - Semi-Attached
MLS ® # 2504316

About Prince’s Bay

Homes for sale in Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, offer a peaceful suburban lifestyle with scenic waterfront views. Located on Staten Island’s South Shore, this neighborhood is bordered by Huguenot to the north and Raritan Bay to the south, providing a serene blend of natural beauty and modern living. With access to Wolfe’s Pond Park and Lemon Creek Park, residents enjoy outdoor activities, breathtaking views, and tranquil surroundings.

Prince’s Bay real estate caters to various budgets and preferences. The median sale price for homes is $855,000, with properties ranging from $339,000 to $2.5 million. Homes here typically sell within 95 days, reflecting a vibrant market. Whether you’re looking for a cozy home or a luxurious waterfront property, Prince’s Bay has options to meet your needs.

The community offers a mix of history and modern convenience. Once known for its oyster beds, the area’s name honors Prince Edward Augustus, Duke of Kent. Today, it features upscale residential developments and scenic parks. The clay bluffs rising above Raritan Bay provide stunning nautical views, adding to the neighborhood’s charm.

Transportation is convenient, with the Staten Island Railway station and local buses like the S55 and S56 serving the area. Express buses SIM25, SIM2, and SIM24 connect Prince’s Bay to other parts of the city. A commuter ferry service is also being considered, further enhancing connectivity.

Prince’s Bay’s family-friendly environment includes playgrounds, sports fields, running trails, and dog parks, making it ideal for those seeking a community-focused lifestyle. The gazebo overlooking Raritan Bay offers a quiet retreat with beautiful views of passing workboats and barges.

Explore homes for sale in Prince’s Bay, Staten Island, to discover a unique neighborhood that combines suburban comfort, natural beauty, and modern amenities. With active listings across a wide price range, Prince’s Bay is a top choice for homebuyers looking to enjoy the best of Staten Island living.

Prince’s Bay Homes For Sale

Prince’s Bay offers a reasonable amount of choice when it comes to housing options – from larger single-family homes to more modest dwellings under $1M. The neighborhood’s recent developments have focused mostly on upscale housing, transforming the waterfront into a sought-after location. This shift has attracted a mix of long-time residents and new arrivals, drawn by the neighborhood’s beauty and its reputation as a quieter, safer part of Staten Island.

Real estate in Prince’s Bay is highly valued, not only for its aesthetic appeal but also for the community’s commitment to preserving its historical landmarks. The neighborhood’s growth has been thoughtfully managed, ensuring that new developments enhance rather than detract from the character of the area. Put another way, Prince’s Bay certainly hasn’t grown faster than it needs to. Because of this, Prince’s Bay remains a desirable place for potential homeowners, especially if you’re in the market for an upscale home.

Be the first to know when new properties in Prince’s Bay become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!

Prince’s Bay Entertainment and Amenities

Prince’s Bay’s residents also have a fair bit of exploring and recreational options at their finger tips. Wolfe’s Pond Park and Lemon Creek Park are central to local life – they provide large green spaces for sports, leisure, and community gatherings. These parks provide playgrounds, sports fields, and trails, making them popular destinations for families and those who simply love being outdoors.

The community also supports a small commercial center, providing the daily necessities to its residents with a variety of shops, restaurants, and services. The revitalization of the waterfront has further enhanced the neighborhood’s appeal, with dining and shopping options that make the absolute most of the stunning bay views. Additionally, the local landmarks and historical sites offer unique cultural experiences that deepen residents’ connections to the area’s past – something that shouldn’t be undervalued.

Education Near Prince’s Bay

Education in Prince’s Bay is served by both public and private education options. Public school students typically attend schools like Margaret Gioiosa Elementary School (P.S. 3) and Elias Bernstein Intermediate School (I.S. 7), both of which are positively viewed schools. Additionally, the neighborhood is home to St. Joseph-St. Thomas School, a private Catholic school offering grades Pre-K through 8, which is another fantastic option if you’re looking for a values-based education.

Beyond this, the New York Public Library’s Huguenot Park Branch serves the Prince’s Bay community with a wealth of programs and services – having a library close by is an amenity that can make a positive difference in your life.

Prince’s Bay FAQ

Q: What healthcare facilities are available in Prince’s Bay?

A: Prince’s Bay residents have access to several healthcare facilities, including the nearby Staten Island University Hospital South Campus. This facility is the southernmost acute-care hospital in New York City.

Q: What are the local crime rates like?

A: Prince’s Bay is known for its low crime rates, contributing to its reputation as a safe and desirable neighborhood, as mentioned above.

Q: What public transportation options are available?

A: Prince’s Bay is also well-connected through the Staten Island Railway and several bus lines, including local and express routes. Plans for a commuter fast ferry service are also being explored, potentially enhancing connectivity to Manhattan. This has the possibility of positively affecting the market value of homes here.

Homes for Sale by Neighborhood

Staten Island

Browse Staten Island Neighborhoods by Region: North Shore, Mid-Island, and South Shore


Let's Find Your Dream Home

Get the info you need, anytime, anywhere. Our site runs smoothly on every device, phone, tablet, or desktop, so you can browse at home or on the go without any issues.

Start Search
(718) 987-7900