Pleasant Plains

Pleasant Plains is a quiet and historically rich neighborhood, located within Staten Island, New York.. Celebrated for its agricultural roots and historical significance, Pleasant Plains offers residents a slower pace of life than the larger cities within Staten Island. The neighborhood offers historical relevance, as well, including the Conference House, a meticulously preserved 17th-century manor.

Exterior shot of a house

Pleasant Plains Real Estate Statistics

Average Price $1.5M
Lowest Price $420K
Highest Price $3.9M
Total Listings 14
Avg. Days On Market 132
Avg. Price/SQFT $437

Property Types (active listings)

Homes For Sale In Pleasant Plains

About Pleasant Plains

Pleasant Plains is a charming little neighborhood located on the Southern shore of Staten Island, New York. Located between Woodrow to the North and the quiet waters of Lower New York Bay to the South, this community is truly worth giving consideration to. The neighborhood's history dates back to 1860, when it was established alongside the new Staten Island Railroad, which spurred its development. Pleasant Plains became known for its welcoming setting, which attracted a community that's still thriving to today. This area is fundamentally a quieter suburb, known for its historically significant Mount Loretto, which is certainly worth seeing if you're in the area.

Today, Pleasant Plains is characterized by its quiet streets, and a welcoming atmosphere that you'd expect from a smaller suburb like this. The community here has access to several parks, most notably is Mount Loretto mentioned above, with fantastic bluffs overlooking Prince's Bay - among the highest ocean-facing cliffs in New York State. Whether you're a family or an individual, we recommend taking a look at the real estate options here - more on the housing options below.

Pleasant Plains Homes For Sale

Housing in Pleasant Plains offers a good variety of options, from quaint single-family homes to newer developments spurred by its growing population. The neighborhood's residential areas are well-maintained, with most homes offering a larger yard ideal for families. As the community has grown, so has the diversity of the housing options - an overall nice mix of old and new.

The real estate market here is attractive due its beautiful surroundings and ease of access throughout the larger parts of Staten Island. The neighborhood's growth has been complemented by a respect for its natural and historical heritage, where many new developments are carefully planned to maintain the area's character that it's known for.

Be the first to know when new properties in Pleasant Plains become available. Register with us for free to get exclusive access to new listings and receive notifications when new homes hit the market!

Pleasant Plains Entertainment and Amenities

Pleasant Plains has plenty for its residents to explore. Beyond Mount Loretto, adjacent Lemon Creek Park provides additional recreational opportunities like boating and fishing. These parks are central to the community's lifestyle, offering residents a chance to unwind in nature and enjoy the best of Staten Island's outdoors.

For shopping and dining, the commercial core at the intersection of Bloomingdale Road, Amboy Road, and Pleasant Plains Ave acts as the neighborhood's hub. The area is experiencing some growth, bringing new shops and restaurants that cater to the tastes of its residents. Additionally, seasonal events and the local market also contribute to the community, making Pleasant Plains a lovely place to visit and live.

Education Near Pleasant Plains

Education in Pleasant Plains is served by a range of public and private options. Public school students typically attend Tottenville High School, a typically well-regarded high school. You'll also find several private school options, including Staten Island Academy, which provides a non-religious, comprehensive educational package from pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade.

The area is also home to specialized educational institutions like South Richmond High School, which focuses on special education, ensuring that all community members have access to quality education. If you have a family, and you're looking for somewhere new to live in Staten Island, Pleasant Plains should be high on your list - you can rest assured that the educational needs of your children would be well taken care of.

Pleasant Plains FAQ

Q: What healthcare facilities are available in Pleasant Plains?

A: Residents here have access to a few healthcare options in Staten Island, including the Staten Island University Hospital South. Of course, you can also find an array of clinics and specialized care within Staten Island as well.

Q: What public transportation options are in Pleasant Plains?

A: If you live in Pleasant Plains, you're well connected by public transportation with Staten Island Railway providing easy access to other parts of the island. Several bus routes, including the S55 local and SIM26 express bus, offer easy access to Manhattan and other boroughs.

Q: What are the crime rates like here?

A: Pleasant Plains enjoys a low crime rate compared to more urbanized areas of New York City, making it a preferred choice for families.

Staten Island Neighborhoods

Start searching for your dream home now.

When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.

Start Search