Real Estate Statistics
| Average Price | $2.3M |
|---|---|
| Lowest Price | $385K |
| Highest Price | $5.4M |
| Total Listings | 4 |
| Avg. Days On Market | 11 |
| Avg. Price/SQFT | $506 |
Property Types (active listings)
Homes For Sale In Old Town
- All Listings
- $300,000 - $400,000
- $800,000 - $900,000
- Over $1,000,000
About Old Town
Residents of Old Town, Staten Island admire its tight-knit community and familiar atmosphere. This neighborhood offers a charming mix of home styles and is located on the eastern part of Staten Island. The surrounding neighborhoods are close enough to be part of an Old Town resident’s life and include Grasmere, Concord, South Beach, and Dongan Hills. Old Town provides a blend of urban and suburban environments with diverse terrain and varying elevations.
Old Town features architectural styles that reflect its rich history, including colonial revival and classic Staten Island designs. Residents have no problem getting around due to the convenient express buses and Staten Island Railway being readily available.
Old Town Parks
A bonus in the neighborhood is the Staten Island Greenbelt Conservancy, which is New York City’s largest remaining forest preserve. People love to hike among wildlife in over 35 miles of marked trails. The beautiful scenery combined with the small-town feel of local shops and restaurants, makes Old Town a calm, attractive residential area.
Old Town History
With the Old Town station of the Staten Island Railway, commuting is convenient. It opened in early 1937 and was originally named "Old Town Road." It was changed to simply “Old Town” by the MTA in the early 1970’s.
Old Town’s historical ties are well-known and admired. In the 1600’s, Old Town was one of the first areas settled by Europeans on Staten Island. The Dutch initially explored the region, and it became part of New Netherland before being taken over by the English in 1664. After the English took control, the village was named Dover. Later, a new area was settled and called Nieuwe Dorp, which translates from Dutch to New Village.
Today, it is now known as New Dorp. Dover was renamed Oude Dorp, meaning Old Village, in an effort to differentiate between the two places. Old Village is now the Old Town neighborhood we know today. What started as farmland and country estates transitioned to a more residential community in the 19th century, all while retaining its rural charm. Old Town lives up to its name as it is known for keeping its historic homes safe while incorporating contemporary constructions, and people are drawn to the unique blend of old and new.
Old Town Homes for Sale
Despite being rich in historic landmarks, Old Town offers a variety of housing options, including townhouses, condos, and multi-family units. However, single-family homes are the most prevalent, providing a residential feel and privacy.
Architectural Style of Old Town Staten Island
The neighborhood features diverse architectural styles such as Dutch Colonial, Victorian, and modern designs, reflecting its rich history. Known for its family-friendly atmosphere and strong sense of community, Old Town provides a peaceful suburban lifestyle with convenient commuting options.
What To Expect From an Old Town Home
Homes in Old Town typically boast spacious yards, perfect for large gardens or pools. Many houses have modern kitchens equipped with updated appliances, ample counter space, and dining areas. Bedrooms are usually comfortable with hardwood floors and generous closet space.
Additionally, it's common to find homes with basements or attics, offering plenty of storage and extra living areas. Many residences preserve unique historical elements like original woodwork, stained glass windows, and period details. Additionally, numerous properties are located near parks, which makes Old Town desirable to families and outdoor enthusiasts who want to explore nature.
Old Town Entertainment & Amenities
Staten Island Greenbelt Conservancy, offers recreational activities such as hiking groups, sports, and fitness classes for all ages and is a notable attraction in Old Town. The neighborhood’s small-town charm, filled with local shops and eateries, makes it a lovely residential community. On Old Town Road, you’ll find Carmel Richmond Healthcare, a well-known Roman Catholic nursing home founded by the Carmelite Order sisters in the 1970s.
Dining Choices in Old Town
Old Town offers delicious, varied choices for dining. You can find Italian, Asian, and American cuisines, family-friendly restaurants, and delis, to name a few. Old Town, Staten Island is perhaps most famous for Royal Crown Bakery, which is widely known for Italian pastries, cakes, and fresh bread. Nearby New Dorp hosts The Boulevard, a shopping center filled with restaurants, retail stores, and more, providing a convenient shopping destination for residents.
Historic Landmarks in Old Town
Did you know that Old Town was the site of one of Staten Island's earliest organized baseball games back in 1855? Residents love that Old Town has historic landmarks blended with the modern-day hustle and bustle. A trip to The Van Pelt Manor house, which was built around 1680, gives a glimpse into Dutch Colonial architecture and life as it belonged to one of Staten Island's earliest Dutch settler families. The Old Town Cemetery on Richmond Road is a historical landmark, where many early settlers were buried.
Old Town Schools
Old Town has public and private schools that cater to diverse needs and preferences. Public schools in the area include elementary school P.S. 46 and middle school I.S. 49. The nearest high school is New Dorp High School, located in the neighboring New Dorp area.
The Academy of St. Dorothy, Roman Catholic private elementary school, is situated on Hylan Boulevard. Additionally, A Very Special Place, a school for developmentally disabled children, is located on Quintard Street. These schools underscore the community's commitment to educational excellence and student development. The Dongan Hills Library, part of the New York Public Library system, It is located at 1617 Richmond Road in neighboring Dongan Hills and features study spaces, children's services, and free internet access, making it an essential educational and community hub for residents.
Old Town FAQ
Q: What are some places to visit in Old Town?
A: Key attractions include local parks, the Staten Island Greenbelt Conservancy, and historical landmarks that remind residents of the neighborhood's roots.
Q: What are transportation options in Old Town?
A: Residents can walk or drive to nearby stores. If they are looking for public transportation options, Old Town features the Staten Island Railway and several local and express bus routes, making commutes easy.
Q: Is Old Town, Staten Island a good place for children?
A: Yes! Not only will children love exploring nature in the parks, but there is a library, restaurants, and shops in the area.
Staten Island Neighborhoods
Start searching for your dream home now.
When it comes to convenience, our site is unparalleled. Whether you're in the comfort of your home, or on the go.
Our site works flawlessly on multiple devices so you can find the information you need.